William Larue Weller Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey, 2011 Buffalo Trace Antique Collection – Review

The name Weller is as intertwined and as important a name as you will find in the history of American whiskey. Daniel Weller was operating a still near Bardstown, KY as early as 1800. His son Samuel followed in his father’s footsteps, and his son, William LaRue Weller started making and selling whiskey in 1849. W.L.Weller is generally credited for being the father of wheated whisky, that is, substituting wheat for rye in the mashbill, and was a strong proponent of aging whisky for longer periods of time. He was both a salesman and an educator, and whiskey with his name on it was always of reliably high quality. Weller’s company was eventually purchased by Julian “Pappy” Van Winkle under whose guidance the relationship with the Stitzel Brothers and their distillery began. After weathering the doldrums of Prohibition, the Stitzel-Weller Distillery officially opened in 1935. Today, the Weller name lives on with the brand being owned by Buffalo Trace. Their range includes the 90 proof W.L. Weller Special Reserve, the 107 proof “Antique”, the 12 Year Old, and this eponymous release which is part of Buffalo Trace’s Antique Collection.

The 2011 William Larue Weller Kentucky Straight Bourbon was distilled from a mashbill of Kentucky corn, North Dakota wheat, and North Dakota malted barley and matured in new American oak (of course) for 12 years and 11 months. It was bottled un-cut and un-filtered from a selection of 45 barrels.

The Nose:  A stunning nose with upfront notes of chocolate covered cherries and strawberries, stewed raisins or even prunes, and believe it or not, coffee beans. A dry, crisp, stone-ground wheat cracker note emerges more as it opens up along with well-toasted walnuts and almonds. Subtler hints of unsweetened cocoa, worn leather, and polished oak balance things out nicely. Water brings out more char notes in the form of burnt popcorn, thin coffee, and a more earthy quality, quieting the fruit a bit and providing an antecedent to the herbaceous notes I found in the palate.

The Palate:  This is mighty powerful stuff but surprisingly smooth at strength and almost mind-blowingly complex. Spirit-y fruit, cherry pie cherries, burnt sugar, burnt toast, a bit of coffee, dark unsweetened chocolate… and rich chocolate fudge all swirl around before a coarse vanilla bean-tinged swell of oak moves in with big, dusty tannins, clove and a faint green herb-y (no, not that kind, you dirty hippy) quality. Water makes this just terrific, coaxing out much more of that wheat cracker graininess and a bit of burnt popcorn while holding on to everything else except those big dusty tannins which are reigned in a bit.

The Finish:  Without water, the finish is a high-octane rush of rich unsweetened chocolate, burnt toast and fermented fruit. With water, the finish retains that slightly sweet but burnt quality and loses a bit of the spirity fruit.

Thoughts:  My god, this one nearly left me speechless, party because of the high alcohol (it accidentally set the curtains on fire which I didn’t notice for almost 2 minutes, so entranced was I by the stuff) and partly because of how damn good it is. At strength, barrel sediment and all, this will slap you around the room and you will like it. The nose is incredibly intriguing and well-balanced, segueing perfectly into a palate that despite it’s nearly overwhelming strength still manages to be hugely complex and impressive. To really sit and enjoy this, I do think it requires a good bit of water (though I think I almost prefer the nose neat). Water does nothing to lessen the complexity, adding deeper notes of the wheated mashbill and generally making it more safe for human consumption. The bottom of my Glencairn glass is layered with fine barrel char and I’m left shaking my head over this beauty. Highly, highly recommended.

William Larue Weller Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey, 2011 Buffalo Trace Antique Collection

66.75% ABV

Score:  92


9 thoughts on “William Larue Weller Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey, 2011 Buffalo Trace Antique Collection – Review

  1. What a coincidence, given that we just reviewed our first bourbon and it was the W.L. Weller 12-year-old. That was absolutely splendid, and I can’t wait to try one of their cask-strength releases!

    1. Thanks Emmet!
      The Antique collection stuff can be hard to find, it comes out in the Fall and is generally pretty sought after. If you can’t find a bottle of this, I’d highly recommend the W.L. Weller 12 year old. It’s much less expensive, not nearly as high alcohol, not quite up to the level of the Antique Collection release, but darn good stuff nonetheless.

  2. Successfully beating the HCV virus after the 3rd 48 week treatment in 9 years, and 14 years since tasting any alcohol, my physicians gave me the go-ahead in moderation. I last tasted Weller`s Special Reserve in 1988. (My first employment at age 9 was cutting wood for a pot still outside of Vonore, Tenn. in 1958. That was “twice run” corn squeezings, hand milled, fresh sprouted grains, pure limestone filtered mountain spring water, no sugar (no burn, non-blinding real “Mountain Dew). Weller`s Special Reserve WAS unparalleled. What have I to look forward to? Changes? How does the Barrel strength compare? “Straight up” sipper.

  3. (continued…: It seems I might have to wait before ending my abstention. The only available source online has the W.Larue Barrel strength at $198. That`s a bit beyond my grasp even after 14+ years. Promises of a new bottling this fall/ winter may have to sustain me as I`d prefer not to compromise my palate on the first taste. The “Winkle” 15 & 20 seems to have disappeared as well. I seem to remember a 10 or 12 year 107 proof “Special Reserve” from the distant past. A bottle can last me a year of sipping. I prefer mine unadulterated, bottled straight- whether 107 or 122/133, with no”taming”. I might just inhale the vapor of a sip for an hour or so before ingesting. At 63, It is one of the few indulgences I can effect and enjoy at the end of a day. Any leads on a “non conventional source?”
    (before Christmas?)- Aloha

  4. I had a taste of the Weller at the recent taste/dinner at the distillery in February and found a new favorite!
    The rye makes it spicier while the wheat has a smoother taste.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.